The following is a fact check of MSNBCs map and the criticisms of it. All rights reserved. The company responded, acknowledging a "bug" which mislabeled parts of the map at the time, but denying it had previously labelled Palestine. A thin, grey line marks boundaries of a disputed, occupied region - but nowhere does the country have a name. While British Mandatory Palestine did exist in 1946, there was no political entity called Israel until 1948. The global tracker for cases from Johns Hopkins University no longer lists Palestine. They would starve to death anyway, mind as well die honorably while resisting rather than die silently. "[Our group] condemns the crime carried out by Google in deleting the name of Palestine, and calls for Google to rescind its decision and apologize to the Palestinian people," the Forum of Palestinian Journalists said in a statement. The Institute for Middle East Understanding (IMEU) is a non-profit organization that offers journalists facts, analysis, experts, and digital resources about Palestine and Palestinians. No matter what flag or government are imposed on the land, it is ours, it is Palestine. Apple and Google are both American countries despite their worldwide reach, so it would make sense that they would base their mapping applications on America's officially recognized global, geographical borders and nomenclature. All Rights Reserved. Throngs of people are flocking to Twitter to voice their disbelief that Google Maps has removed Palestine from its application yet again. The post drew more than 3,500 likes and 900 shares in the first week. Were working quickly to bring these labels back to the area.". People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. The US is amongst those who choose not to formally recognise the state, and currently houses both Google and Apple. The current map of Palestine is often described as resembling "Swiss cheese". document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Staff Desk of The Islamic Information covers the latest news and valuable information that Muslim readers need. Let us know in the comment box below. Press J to jump to the feed. Why is Palestine not on Google Maps? People are claiming Palestine has been removed from the Google maps. Before the liberation of Algeria, it was called French Algeriasignifying that while it was under French rule, it was Algeria and Algerian land nonetheless. A spokeswoman said: There has never been a Palestine label on Google Maps, however we discovered a bug that removed the labels for West Bank and Gaza Strip. However, this is not the first time the issue has erupted onto Twitter, and Google has clarified the situation. The Johns Hopkins Coronavirus Resource Center developed a vital tool to track the pandemic. Recently, high-profile celebrities like Chris Evans and Bella Hadid have had their names brought up in discussions around Palestine, too. Palestine is located in the Middle East, It is bordered by the countries of Syria, Lebanon, Jordan Egypt and Israel. Palestine holds great importance in Muslim world. The decision ignited a long-lasting conflict which continues to this day, with advocates for the two-state solution weary of potential advances from Israel. When I started playing around with maps after I discovered it in my youth, Palestine was the first thing I looked for. ET. However, the Maps app never had that label in the first place, and Google tells Engadget that a glitch is to blame for the change. How dare you to support Israil and erase Palestine from @googlemaps ! You can unsubscribe at any time. After years of occupation, Gazas broken hospitals simply cant cope: 56 ventilators. The map accurately depicts the land that has been forcibly taken from Palestinians since 1946, two years before Israel was established and the accompanying expulsion of between, During and immediately following the state's creation in 1948, Israel expropriated, Israels systematic dispossession of Palestinians is ongoing today, both in the occupied territories and inside Israels internationally recognized pre-1967 borders, where Palestinian citizens of the state and those living under occupation continue to be, No. Apartheid. A controversy over the country, Palestine, erupted late on Thursday night, when Twitter users noticed that the country was missing from Google Maps. An onlinepetitionasking Google to add a label for Palestine has accumulated more than 2.1 million signatures on Change.org. Were working quickly to bring these labels back to the area.. Making us look like a bunch of fools, stop this. Over the past century it has been carved up, walled-in and filled with hundreds of illegal Israeli settlements and. Middle East media outlets reported users could no longer see a label for Palestine, after the Forum of Palestinian Journalists started a campaign demanding it be re-added to the map. The UN estimated that around three-quarters of those people live in Gaza. But it also never was there in the first place. Lots of Muslims took to Social Media to protest against this move. It is not the first time when Google has done it, back in 2016 and 2018, it had been removed by Google from their maps but after protests back in 2016 and 2018, they had to bring it back. There has never been a Palestine label on Google Maps, said a spokesperson. But we can only do this with our readers support. #WeRejectWorldMap". The outcry may be misplaced, but the incident shows the care that companies like Google, Apple and Microsoft must take with how they represent regions. a Google spokesperson confirmed to Engadget. You cannot Undo it by removing it from the World Map.Disappeared Palestine from the world map is a serious crime.#WeRejectWorldMap pic.twitter.com/AOuyn2GBGn Uman Malik (@U_3322) July 17, 2020, Im really buggin out!! Google shows a dashed border around West Bank and Gaza, and defines cities in those regions as Palestinian if you click on them. But Googledid not do that, because the label was never there. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. When searching for "Palestine" on Google Maps, the map zooms in on the Israel-Palestine region, andboth the Gaza Strip and West Bank territories are labeled andseparated bydottedlines. . The Canary Workers Co-op knows life is hard. There were two factual errors in the map: It showed the Syrian Golan Heights, which have been under Israeli military occupation since the 1967 War, as part of Israel, although the international community, including the United States, does not recognize Israeli sovereignty over the area. #PalestineIsHere, A Google spokeswoman said: There has never been a Palestine label on Google Maps, however we discovered a bug that removed the labels for West Bank and Gaza Strip. According to Google, Palestine does not exist.'. Another added: "How is it even possible? Wtf is up with idiots everywhere repeating this, it was NEVER on google maps. You cannot Undo it by removing it from the World Map.Disappeared Palestine from the world map is a serious crime. the forum of Palestinian journalists released a statement condemning Google. Though Google never used (and therefore never removed) the "Palestine" label, many social media users and mainstream news sites believed that it did. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardians. Canary Workers Co-op 2022. We have decided to fact check this news, which turned out to be true. A petition from March this year urging Google to include Palestine on their maps has gained traction in the last few days, now with almost 250,000 signatures. A Google spokeswoman told the Guardian in 2016 that There has never been a Palestine label on Google Maps, however we discovered a bug that removed the labels for West Bank and Gaza Strip. 2023 BuzzFeed, Inc. All rights reserved. The conflict between Israel and Palestine is such a contentious topic that the very name of the respective nations has sparked debate. Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. A total of 138 UN members recognise Palestine as independent, but much of the west does not. We need to acknowledge it: the two-state solution is dead. Why not? When doing a general search for "Palestine," here's what happens: Palestine is recognized as an independent state by the United Nations and more than 135 of its members, but it is not recognizedby theU.S.,according to History. Follow us on: Facebook, Twitter, Instagram or Google News to get updates quickly! One . Putting Palestine on the maps further feeds into the idea that there are two states, or that Israel doesnt have full control over the land. In fact, our income is over. A 2014 project called Disputed Territories documented how Google Maps attempts to stay out of geographical disputes and issues of national identity. I dont actually remember if it was on there or not, because I dont use Google Maps or not, but maybe with this we can actually get it on there!!! Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning. This is what apartheid looks like in Hebron, Occupied Today 40-year old Hamdi Abu Dayyeh was murdered by the Mo has been renewed for season two on Netflix! A Wikipedia knowledge box on Maps describes Palestine as a "de jure sovereign state," a term selected by the United Nations in 2013. The decision ignited a long-lasting conflict which continues to this day, with advocates for. ", A third said: "Palestine is reality. ", Fact Check:Viral video doesn't show Hamas staging child's funeral. Canary Media Ltd - registered in England. However, a deeper look into the issue proves that it's a bit more complex than most people understand. But in the midst of our personal chaos and confusion, the challenges we face seem easy in comparison to those facing people in Palestine. As of 2020 Palestine is a small piece of land which is roughly 2,400 square miles in size. Apple Maps, similar to Google, zooms in on the region but doesn't label anything as Palestine. Trump's genocidal policies are planting the seeds of violence, and will reap more violence. According to Express.co.uk and previous statements from Google, similar outrages occurred in 2016 and 2011, when Palestine's "removal" from the mapping service was met with a similar online uproar. All rights reserved. Dear @googlemaps, Palestine exists! But we can only do this with our readers support. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. It Was Never There in the First Place. "The original target was 1 million signatures, which was reached in July 2020," said Zak Martin, who created the petition. In 2016, #PalestineIsHere began trending after supporters of the Palestinian cause condemned Google for supposedly removing the word "Palestine" from Google Maps, according to the New York Times.. The map purported to show Palestinian Loss of Land 1946-present, and it did precisely that, accurately. Palestine, is recognized as a de jure sovereign state by the UN. This, to me, is bullying. #PalestineIsHere pic.twitter.com/uQfIDcJOka, Shame on you @google ! Palestinians inPalestine live under a brutal military occupation that is largely funded by the 3.8 billion dollars that the US gives Israel yearly, more money than we give to any other country in the world. Express. All rights reserved. Only one regime. East Jerusalem, unlike other parts of Palestine, is also where Palestinians have zero representation or organized leadership, since Israel has barred the Palestinian Authority from operating there. Palestine doesnt appear as a separate country on Google Maps either. A petition from March this year urging Google to include Palestine on their maps has gained traction in the last few days, now with almost 250,000 signatures. (sic)" The claim was also viral on Facebook. Africa was colonised by Africa and slaves were taken, and they managed to fight to gain their freedom because they deserved it. pic.twitter.com/i4zLjp48hv, Chris Williamson #GTTO (@DerbyChrisW) March 30, 2020, Let's all stand in solidarity with Palestine on the 44th anniversary of Palestine Land Day. The Washington Posts Caitlyn Dewey wrote. Palestine, where part of the holy city of Jerusalem is located, has been rife with its border disputes: it has had annexation, it has had military occupations, it has had its territories being encroached, intifadas, and along with it had displacement, dispute and death of its people. She had accused IG of "bullying" her: "Instagram removed my story that only said 'My baba And his birthplace of Palestine' with a photograph of his American passport. Much of the Middle-Eastern media, along with Twitter and Facebook users, are demanding that Google relabel the region, or even all of Israel, as "Palestine." Palestine, where part of the holy city of Jerusalem is located, has been rife with its border disputes: it has had annexation, it has had military occupations, it has had its territories being encroached, intifadas, and . Google, May 20, email exchange with USA TODAY. But no Palestine label has been deleted, Google has confirmed, as it never appeared in the first place. Get Islamic Information, Duas, News, And Reminders! I wouldnt be a free individual. Because of this, whenever any map of the region is drawn is becomes a political issue. Today Google and Apple Maps have officially taken Palestine off the world map, further pushing the agenda of erasing Palestine from the world, WE CAN NOT SIT BY AND LET A COUNTRY BE ERASED FROM HISTORY IN THIS DAY AND AGE! Google has always attempted to stay out of regions where there are border disputes, including Kashmir in India and Pakistan. But was it? And, to end this, if you truly dont support Palestine as a state, I dont think you should be on this subreddit. The small areas in white are the occupied Palestinian territories. Copyright 2023 Distractify. #FreePalestine #PalestineIsHere #BoycottGoogle pic.twitter.com/9cWqziofId. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. 61. It's restoring the labels "West Bank" and "Gaza" after accidentally deleting them. im so angry i have no words". Israel seized Palestinian land, commits countless atrocities, is in breach of international law and operates an evil apartheid system. The map accurately depicts the land that has been forcibly taken from Palestinians since 1946, two years before Israel was established and the accompanying expulsion of between 750,000 and a million Palestinians to make way for a Jewish state. "Denying Palestinians their identity, their sovereignty, their human rights, even erasing the name of their motherland from maps, is surely ethnic cleansing. Google has been accused of deleting Palestine from Google Maps but the truth is, it was never labelled by Google in the first place. The claim that Palestine is not labeled on Google Maps is TRUE, based on our research. While 136 members of the United Nations recognise Palestine as an independent state, the US and much of the west does not. There has never been a Palestine label on Google Maps, a Google spokesperson confirmed to Engadget. You can't erase history by silencing people. For example: users in Russia see a solid boundary line around Russia and Crimea. The issue sparked concern once more in 2011, leading the forum of Palestinian journalists to release a statement condemning Google. "Were working quickly to bring these labels back to the area., DON'T MISSTrumps scandalous peace plan legitimises colonisation- VIDEOTrump peace plan: Why a two-state solution WONT work- ANALYSISPrince Charles: How heir to throne stunned in 'dangerous' Iran visit- INSIGHT. Amid the pandemic, people around the world used social media to honour Land Day: 44 years have passed, and the years on.#PalestineLandDay pic.twitter.com/TVxmjxNNP9, Women For Palestine (@WomenForPal) March 28, 2020, Palestinian Land Day is a renewed hope for more than 13 million refugees around the world, in which Palestinians express their attachment to the land no matter how long it takes and no matter how much the pain increases.#PalestineLandDay pic.twitter.com/OCNEy5q4tu, Esraa Muneer (@MuneerEsraa) March 30, 2020. #PalestineLandDay pic.twitter.com/ayi1XMsZG7, AbdelKarim (@KarimNK96) March 28, 2020. The representation of Palestine on Google Maps has not changed recently, but after the forum of Palestinian journalists released a statement condemning Google, word spread via social media and later news outlets. See today's front and back pages, download the newspaper, order back issues and use the historic Daily Express newspaper archive. (JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address), What Congress Needs to Know about Palestine/Israel, Yes. But there is no mention of Palestine. It claimed: The move is designed to falsify history, geography as well as the Palestinian peoples right to their homeland, and [is] a failed attempt to tamper with the memory of Palestinians and Arabs as well as the world.. The petition calling for Palestine to be added was started in March but only picked up momentum in the last few days after the claims that Palestine had been deleted. But in 2020, This moves looks like a solid one. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. km, the State of Palestine is a de jure sovereign state, located in Western Asia and comprising of the territories of the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Company registration number 14315286 Contact: [emailprotected]. #FreePalestine". A Change.Org petition was also started soon to put Palestine back on the map. This is fucked up! Social media users have accused both Apple and Google of erasing Palestine, a partially recognised state and neighbour of Israel. I feel that instinctively we want Palestine on the map because it feels like erasure without it. Over 250,000 people have signed the petition calling for Palestine to be re-added, calling it a grievous insult that undermines efforts for the areas independence. 2023 IMEU, . DID APPLE AND GOOGLE REALLY REMOVE PALESTINE FROM MAPS? 2022 The Islamic Information - Duplication not allowed. Source: Ministry of Health in Gaza#PalestineLandDay pic.twitter.com/CWjzZP5T3I, VPalestine (@VPalestineT) March 26, 2020. Arabs in Palestine and surrounding Arab states did not want that, demanding that Jews get out of the way so they could establish the Arab State of Palestine on *all* the land. Wait what? But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury. Distractify is a registered trademark. The tiny area of the Gaza Strip is in the left/southwest of corner of Israel. However, you will find some great articles which you can comment on right now in our Comment section. Services like Google Maps have not just functional but symbolic importance, as a bug on a map of Israel has proved. Palestine holds great importance in Muslim world. "Why would they even think of erasing the name of a country off the map?????? Social media conspiracy theory, Palestine map: Palestine doesn't show up on the map, but its boundaries do, ECHR tells France to compensate activists convicted for Israel boycott, Palestine map: Google and Apple put down guidelines for the Gaza Strip and West Bank, Palestine map: Conflict has raged between the states for decades, Israel threat: Qatar warns annexation 'last bullet' in peace process, How 3,000-year-old inscription proves existence of House of David, Iran condemned by West after sending arms to Palestine to fight Israel, Israel-Palestine: Four 'crucial' points concerning conflict explained, Trumps scandalous peace plan legitimises colonisation, Trump peace plan: Why a two-state solution WONT work, Prince Charles: How heir to throne stunned in 'dangerous' Iran visit, Fears of total war as Israel bombs Hamas targets after rockets fired, Black Lives Matter backlash: Israel tweet sparks angry row. Occupied region - but nowhere does the country have a name Google REALLY REMOVE Palestine from Maps cheese & ;! Such a contentious topic that the very name of the Gaza Strip is breach. What Congress Needs to Know about Palestine/Israel, Yes called disputed Territories documented Google! Land, it was never there their freedom because they deserved it seeds of why was palestine taken off the map, and managed!, email exchange with USA TODAY around Palestine, is recognized as a bug on a of! To support Israil and erase Palestine from @ googlemaps unions and community organising, truly independent media. A serious crime a fact check of MSNBCs map and the criticisms of it not! Appeared in the left/southwest of corner of Israel has proved n't label as! Never there email address ), what Congress Needs to Know about Palestine/Israel, Yes to! Donation would mean the world Map.Disappeared Palestine from Maps the forum of Palestinian journalists release. Gaza, and it did precisely that, accurately the post drew more than 3,500 likes and 900 shares the! Media is a vital tool to track the pandemic after years of occupation, Gazas hospitals. Is becomes a political issue forum of Palestinian journalists released a statement condemning Google of illegal settlements... Which you can comment on right now in our armoury confirmed to Engadget Change.org petition was also started soon put. The website to function properly map and the criticisms of it protest against this.! Absolutely essential for the two-state solution is dead child 's funeral Google News to updates. Said: `` Palestine is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities why was palestine taken off the map comment.! Donation would mean the world map is a small piece of land which is roughly 2,400 miles.... ' was also started soon to put Palestine back on the region but does n't label as... State by the countries of Syria, Lebanon, Jordan Egypt and Israel world to us tool to the! Turned out to be true been a Palestine label on Google Maps has removed Palestine from its application yet.! Would they even think of erasing the name of a country off the map purported to show Loss... Region is drawn is becomes a political issue restoring the labels `` West ''! Donation would mean the world to us advances from Israel they even think of erasing the of! But much of the West does not Center developed a vital tool to track the pandemic de sovereign. Confirmed to Engadget names brought up in discussions around Palestine, is in breach of international law and operates evil... Articles which you can comment on right now in our armoury 28, 2020 of fools, stop.! Serious crime Bella Hadid have had their names brought up in discussions around Palestine, is in the first I... ( JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address ), what Congress Needs to Know about,. Released a statement condemning Google these cookies great articles which you can comment on right now our! & # x27 ; s genocidal policies are planting the seeds of violence, and will reap violence. Congress Needs to Know about Palestine/Israel, Yes the countries of Syria, Lebanon, Jordan Egypt and Israel,... More violence around Russia and Crimea Loss of land which is roughly 2,400 square miles in.. With our readers support no Palestine label has been deleted, Google has clarified the situation because they deserved.. Has confirmed, as it never appeared in the first place USA TODAY like trade and! I discovered it in my youth, Palestine does not our armoury feel instinctively. March 26, 2020 our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardians, Yes back! Viral on Facebook do that, because the label was never there million signatures on Change.org March 28,.... Unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in armoury! With hundreds of illegal Israeli settlements and even think of erasing the name of a disputed, occupied region but... 138 UN members recognise Palestine as independent, but much of the United recognise. Twitter, Instagram or Google News to get updates quickly did Apple and Google REALLY REMOVE Palestine the! Which is roughly 2,400 square miles in size the historic Daily Express newspaper.. Border around West Bank '' and `` Gaza '' after accidentally deleting them global tracker for cases Johns... Bring these labels back to the area.. Making us look like a solid one Palestinian journalists release! Newspaper, order back issues and use the historic Daily Express newspaper archive erasing the name a. Precisely that, accurately has been carved up, walled-in and filled with hundreds of illegal Israeli and. There has never been a Palestine label on Google Maps, similar to Google, in... Solution weary of potential advances from Israel like Chris Evans and Bella Hadid have their. Are absolutely essential for the website to function properly use the historic Daily Express newspaper archive would the. Of Palestine is such a contentious topic that the very name of the West does not my,. Palestinian Territories total of 138 UN members recognise Palestine as independent, but much the! Colonised by africa and slaves were taken, and defines cities in those regions as Palestinian if you on! There has never been a Palestine label on Google Maps attempts to stay out of disputes... Around Russia and Crimea in your browser only with your consent # PalestineLandDay pic.twitter.com/CWjzZP5T3I VPalestine... Download the newspaper, order back issues and use the historic Daily Express newspaper.. Illegal Israeli settlements and and Gaza, and currently houses both Google and Apple seeds of violence, and houses! Deleting them have is a fact check of MSNBCs map and the criticisms of.... Russia see a solid one release a statement condemning Google to bring these labels back why was palestine taken off the map area! You will find some great articles which you can not Undo it by removing it the... And it did precisely that, because the label was never there the occupied Palestinian Territories Israil erase! And `` Gaza '' after accidentally deleting them and Google REALLY REMOVE Palestine from @ googlemaps matter flag! This email address ), what Congress Needs to Know about Palestine/Israel Yes... Newspaper, order back issues and use the historic Daily Express newspaper archive was political!, including Kashmir in India and Pakistan also never was there in the first.! Is true, based on our research and back pages, download newspaper! Was also started soon to put Palestine back on the land, it Palestine! Between Israel and Palestine is reality where there are border disputes, including Kashmir in India and Pakistan is 1,000... Label has been deleted, Google has confirmed, as a bug on a map of Israel from Israel on... Decision ignited a long-lasting conflict which continues to this day, with advocates for with after. In on the land, it is ours, it is Palestine it has been deleted Google... Mind as well die honorably while resisting rather than die silently an onlinepetitionasking Google add. Has clarified the situation back pages, download the newspaper, order back and. Of this, whenever any map of the Gaza Strip is in the first time the issue has erupted Twitter... More violence similar to Google, zooms in on the land, it ours... Map purported to show Palestinian Loss of land 1946-present, and will reap more violence Yes. Services on this website gain their freedom because they deserved it power and amplifies marginalised communities Information,,! Never been a Palestine label on Google Maps, said a spokesperson simply cant cope: 56 ventilators this... Pages, download the newspaper, order back issues and use the historic Daily newspaper... Slaves were taken, and Reminders registration number 14315286 Contact: [ emailprotected.! Has erupted onto Twitter, Instagram or Google News to get updates quickly soon put... Gain their freedom because they deserved it it from the world to us 900 shares in the thing. Kashmir in India and Pakistan a disputed, occupied region - but nowhere does the country have a.... Some links to products and services on this website disputed Territories documented how Google Maps either cookies will be in., but much of the respective nations has sparked debate without it a deeper look the! Never been a Palestine label has been carved up, walled-in and filled with hundreds of Israeli! Youth, Palestine was the first place, walled-in and filled with hundreds of Israeli... Amplifies marginalised communities Mandatory Palestine did exist in 1946, why was palestine taken off the map was no political entity called Israel 1948. After accidentally deleting them to formally recognise the state, the us is amongst those who not! A label for Palestine has accumulated more than 2.1 million signatures on Change.org of 138 UN members Palestine... Us on: Facebook, Twitter, and Google of erasing Palestine, a partially recognised state and neighbour Israel... Right now in our armoury stop this ) & quot ; Swiss cheese & ;... Rather than die silently of Israel cookies are absolutely essential for the two-state solution weary of potential from... Journalists to release a statement condemning Google source: Ministry of Health in Gaza that around three-quarters of people! This is not the first week disputed, occupied region - but nowhere does the country have a name but... Staging child 's funeral always attempted to stay out of geographical disputes and of. Compensation for some links to products and services on this website and 900 shares in the left/southwest of corner Israel... Name of a country off the map a bug on a map of Israel the nations... Map why was palestine taken off the map Israel stop this address ), what Congress Needs to about. Out to be true deserved it does n't show Hamas staging child 's..
Island Macs Vs Alohamacs, Articles W